Skip to content

Who Was the Real St. Nicholas? Facts vs. Legend

The man behind Santa Claus was a bishop of Myra, in today's Turkey, who lived about 1,700 years ago. Little is certain about his life, and his famous stories are legends.

The pale stone Basilica of St. Nicholas in Bari, Italy, with its arched portal and tall gable, people walking in the square
Image: Photo: Bernard Gagnon / CC0

The real St. Nicholas was a Christian bishop of Myra, a city in Lycia on the southern coast of what is now Turkey, who lived in the 300s. Almost nothing about his life is documented, and the famous stories about him, including the gold for three sisters, are legends.

That bishop is the root of Sinterklaas in the Netherlands, the boots children set out in Germany and Austria, and, through Dutch New York, Santa Claus. His feast day is December 6, which in 2026 falls on a Sunday, so the evening of Saturday, December 5, is when children put out their boots and shoes.

What Do We Actually Know About St. Nicholas?

St. Nicholas of Myra was a 4th-century bishop in Lycia. The Catholic Encyclopedia says there is "scarcely anything historically certain about him" beyond that.

His traditional death date is December 6, which is why his feast falls on that day. The year is uncertain: sources give dates from 343 to 352. Tradition says he attended the Council of Nicaea in 325, but the Catholic Encyclopedia notes there is "reason to doubt his presence" there.

He was remembered early, though. As early as the 6th century, Emperor Justinian I built a church in his honor in Constantinople.

Which Stories Are Legend?

The famous stories about Nicholas are legends, not documented history. The best known is the tale of the three dowries: a poor man cannot afford dowries for his three daughters, and without one they are unlikely to marry. Gold then appears in the house on three separate nights.

That story is the reason the saint became linked with secret gifts, and with stockings and shoes filled overnight. Sailors also claimed him as their patron and spread stories of his protection, and St. Nicholas chapels were built in many seaports. He is also the patron saint of children, merchants, bakers and travelers.

Why Are His Bones in Bari, Italy?

St. Nicholas's remains lie in Bari, in southern Italy, because sailors and merchants from Bari took them from his tomb in Myra in 1087. They arrived in Bari on May 9, 1087, to crowds at the harbor. By October 1089, Pope Urban II had placed the relics beneath the altar of the new crypt, where they still rest.

Bari celebrates the arrival every May. Not everyone sees it as a happy event: the Catholic Encyclopedia says plainly that the merchants "stole his body." Venice also holds relics, smaller bones the Bari sailors missed in their hurry, kept at the Lido of Venice.

Since 1966 the crypt in Bari has also had an Orthodox chapel, so Catholic and Orthodox Christians both pray at his tomb.

What Did St. Nicholas Look Like?

A 2014 facial reconstruction shows a middle-aged man with a long beard, a round head, a square jaw and a severely broken nose that healed unevenly. It was made by Caroline Wilkinson and Mark Roughley at the Face Lab of Liverpool John Moores University, and it updated a model Wilkinson built in 2004 at the University of Manchester.

The work used measurements and X-rays of the skull taken by Luigi Martino, an anatomy professor at the University of Bari, when the bones were temporarily removed during repairs to the crypt in the 1950s. "We did not have the physical skull," Wilkinson said, so the portrait is an informed estimate. She called it "the closest we are ever going to get to him."

Boots and Shoes on December 5 and 6

In Austria and Germany, December 6 is Nikolaustag, St. Nicholas Day. In Austria he is also called Nikolo. On the night before, children put out a boot, or a shoe or stocking if they have no boots, hoping he will fill it.

Children polish the boot to show they have been good, and they usually set out just one, so they don't look greedy. Sometimes Nikolaus leaves only a wooden switch. In parts of Austria he comes with a scary helper, Krampus, whom our guide to strange Christmas traditions covers separately.

In Austria, the Christmas presents themselves come later, on Christmas Eve, from the Christkind (the Christ Child). St. Nicholas's visit is a separate event.

When Did Sinterklaas Arrive in 2026?

Sinterklaas is the Dutch name for St. Nicholas, and his arrival each November is a national event in the Netherlands. In 2026 the national arrival, covered by Dutch public broadcaster NTR, was held in Grave, a town in North Brabant, on Saturday, November 14.

How Did Sinterklaas Become Santa Claus?

Santa Claus got his name from Sinterklaas. Dutch immigrants to New York celebrated St. Nicholas's feast day under the nickname "Sinter Klaas," short for "Sint Nicholaas."

Writer Washington Irving gave the saint a literary role in A History of New York, published in 1809. The first edition mentions St. Nicholas as the city's patron saint, and a revised 1812 edition added many more references, including St. Nicholas as a midwinter gift-giver. The book never uses the name Santa Claus.

The poem "A Visit from St. Nicholas" followed on December 23, 1823, when the Troy, New York, Sentinel printed it anonymously. It gave the gift-giver "a miniature sleigh, and eight tiny reindeer," and has him come down the chimney. Our article on whether Coca-Cola invented Santa's red suit traces how his look developed afterward.

Is St. Nicholas the Same as Santa Claus?

St. Nicholas and Santa Claus are separate figures with a shared ancestor. Nicholas was a bishop honored by Catholic and Orthodox Christians on December 6, while Santa Claus is a Christmas gift-giver who developed in the United States.

The traits linking them are gift-giving, the connection to children and the December date. Many details of Santa, from the sleigh to the reindeer, came from writers and illustrators in the 1800s, not from the bishop.

Key facts

Who he was
Bishop of Myra, in Lycia, in the 4th century
Where Myra was
The southern coast of today's Turkey
Feast day
December 6 (a Sunday in 2026)
Relics
Arrived in Bari, Italy, on May 9, 1087
Facial reconstruction
2014, Liverpool John Moores University Face Lab
Sinterklaas national arrival 2026
Saturday, November 14, in Grave, the Netherlands
Irving's History of New York
Published 1809, revised 1812
"A Visit from St. Nicholas"
First printed December 23, 1823

Questions people ask

Was Santa Claus a real person?

Santa Claus himself is a character, but he grew out of a real person: St. Nicholas, a 4th-century bishop of Myra, in today's Turkey. Many details of Santa were added by writers and artists in the 1800s.

When is St. Nicholas Day in 2026?

St. Nicholas Day is December 6, 2026, a Sunday. In Austria and Germany, children put out a boot on the evening of December 5.

Where are the bones of St. Nicholas?

Most are in the crypt of the Basilica of St. Nicholas in Bari, Italy, where they arrived in 1087. Venice holds smaller bones at the Lido.

Why do children put shoes out for St. Nicholas?

The custom goes back to the legend that Nicholas secretly left gold for a poor family. Children leave a boot or shoe so he can fill it overnight.

Did St. Nicholas go to the Council of Nicaea?

Tradition says he did, in 325, but historians have reason to doubt it. Very little about his life can be confirmed.

Sources

  1. St. Nicholas of Myra (Catholic Encyclopedia, New Advent) · newadvent.org
  2. Who is St. Nicholas? (St. Nicholas Center) · stnicholascenter.org
  3. The Saint in Bari (St. Nicholas Center) · stnicholascenter.org
  4. Relics (St. Nicholas Center) · stnicholascenter.org
  5. The Real Face of St. Nicholas (St. Nicholas Center) · stnicholascenter.org
  6. Why Nikolaustag is celebrated before Christmas (The Local) · thelocal.com
  7. Landelijke intocht Sinterklaas 2026 in Grave (Hart van Nederland, from NTR) · hartvannederland.nl
  8. Revisiting the Knickerbocker Origin Story of Santa (History News Network) · historynewsnetwork.org
  9. A Visit from Santa...Who You Might Not Recognize (Library of Congress blog) · blogs.loc.gov

More in Wow Facts

All 69 articles