Coca-Cola did not invent Santa Claus or his red suit. Santa appeared in a red coat in print decades before the company hired illustrator Haddon Sundblom in 1931, and the company says so itself: "Santa appeared in a red coat before Sundblom painted him."
What Coca-Cola did do was spend about 30 years of Christmas advertising making one friendly, human-looking version of Santa the version nearly everyone pictures.
The Claim
The claim is that Santa Claus wore green, brown or blue until Coca-Cola began advertising with him, and that the company picked red and white to match its own brand colors.
The idea is easy to believe because Sundblom's paintings for Coca-Cola ran in national magazines every December for more than 30 years. The question is what Santa looked like before the first of them appeared in 1931.
What Did Santa Look Like Before Coca-Cola?
Before 1931, Santa had no fixed look, and red was only one of the colors artists used. The evidence runs from a fourth-century bishop to magazine covers of the early 1900s.
Saint Nicholas of Myra
Saint Nicholas was a Greek Christian bishop of Myra, a Roman city in Lycia, in what is now Demre, Turkey. He lived in the late 200s and early 300s. In 1087, merchants from Bari, Italy, took most of his bones to Bari.
1823: "A Visit from St. Nicholas"
The poem "A Visit from St. Nicholas," better known as "'Twas the Night Before Christmas," was first published anonymously in the Troy, New York, Sentinel on December 23, 1823. Clement Clarke Moore later claimed it, but the family of Henry Livingston Jr. also claimed it, and some modern scholars back Livingston.
Whoever wrote it, the poem never says Santa's clothes were red. It describes fur clothing "tarnished with ashes and soot," along with a white beard, rosy cheeks, a pipe and a plump, jolly build.
1863: Thomas Nast in Harper's Weekly
Cartoonist Thomas Nast drew "Santa Claus in Camp" for the January 3, 1863, issue of Harper's Weekly. It shows Santa in a Union army camp during the Civil War, dressed in stars and stripes and holding a puppet of Confederate president Jefferson Davis. The Library of Congress holds it as a wood engraving, and the magazine printed it in black and white.
Nast kept drawing Santa for Harper's Weekly for decades, and his best-known version, "Merry Old Santa Claus," ran on January 1, 1881. The Library of Congress says Santa's red coat, pipe, workshop and North Pole home all first appeared in Nast's Santa drawings. The magazine itself, though, was printed in black and white, so the clearest early evidence of a red Santa comes from color prints.
Not every Santa was red
In an 1864 edition of Moore's poem, Santa appears in blue, green and yellow. A Santa in an 1868 "Sugar Plums" advertisement wears a red jacket and a green hat. In 1902, L. Frank Baum's book The Life and Adventures of Santa Claus pictured Santa in a black coat with leopard-skin trim and red boots, and a 1906 Eaton's catalogue showed a suit trimmed in black.
1902 to 1904: Puck's red-and-white Santas
Santa appeared in red and white on several covers of the humor magazine Puck in the first few years of the 1900s. The Public Domain Review says Frank A. Nankivell's cover of December 3, 1902, may be the first Santa "indistinguishable from that of the present day." The Library of Congress holds the original chromolithograph, a color print made from stone plates.
1915 and 1923: White Rock
White Rock Beverages used a Santa figure to sell mineral water in 1915 and to sell ginger ale in 1923, including a December 1923 ad showing Santa drinking White Rock ginger ale. That put Santa in drinks advertising years before Coca-Cola's Sundblom paintings.
What Coca-Cola's Own Santas Looked Like
Coca-Cola's early Santas were not the jolly figure of today. The company says its Christmas advertising began in the 1920s with shopping-themed magazine ads, and the first Santa ads "used a strict-looking Claus, in the vein of Thomas Nast."
In 1930, Fred Mizen painted a department-store Santa for a Coca-Cola ad in The Saturday Evening Post. Sundblom's Santa debuted in Coke ads in the same magazine in 1931.
Sundblom first painted from a live model, his friend Lou Prentiss, a retired salesman. After Prentiss died, Sundblom used himself in a mirror, and later he worked from photographs. Coca-Cola ads featured his Santa from 1931 to 1964, and his final version was painted in 1964.
Coca-Cola says those paintings made Santa "a warm, happy character with human features," including "rosy cheeks, a white beard, twinkling eyes and laughter lines." The company also says "Coca-Cola did not create the legend of Santa Claus."
The Verdict
Verdict: Myth. Coca-Cola did not invent Santa Claus or his red suit: color prints showed Santa in red by 1868, Puck's 1902 Christmas cover showed a red-and-white Santa much like today's, and Coca-Cola itself says Santa wore red before Sundblom painted him.
The company's real contribution was consistency. Its ads showed the same warm, white-bearded, red-suited Santa across 33 years of national magazine advertising, which helped fix one version in the public mind.
How Santa Got His Look
| Year | Image | Color of the suit |
|---|---|---|
| Late 200s to 300s | Saint Nicholas, bishop of Myra (now Demre, Turkey) | Not applicable |
| 1823 | "A Visit from St. Nicholas," published in the Troy Sentinel | Fur, covered in ashes and soot; no red |
| 1863 | Nast, "Santa Claus in Camp," Harper's Weekly, January 3 | Stars and stripes; printed in black and white |
| 1864 | Illustrated edition of Moore's poem | Blue, green and yellow among the colors used |
| 1868 | "Sugar Plums" advertisement | Red jacket, green hat |
| 1881 | Nast, "Merry Old Santa Claus," Harper's Weekly, January 1 | Printed in black and white; the Library of Congress credits Nast's Santas with the red coat |
| 1902 | Nankivell cover, Puck, December 3 | Red and white, like today's Santa |
| 1915 and 1923 | White Rock mineral water and ginger ale ads | Santa used in drinks ads before Coca-Cola's paintings |
| 1920s | First Coca-Cola Santa ads, in magazines | Strict-looking Santa in the style of Nast |
| 1931 | Sundblom's first Coca-Cola Santa, The Saturday Evening Post | Red coat, white beard, rosy cheeks |
| 1964 | Sundblom's final Santa for Coca-Cola | Same look, after 33 years |





