Skip to content

Why Does Bread Go Stale? It Isn’t Just Drying Out

Bread goes stale as starch molecules reorganise and moisture shifts, not simply because it dries out. Starch retrogradation can be fastest at 4°C, which is why a fridge may make bread firm sooner.

A basket filled with assorted rolls and loaves, including sesame and multigrain breads.
Image: 3268zauber / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Bread has a soft interior, called the crumb, and an outer crust. Heat alters the crumb’s starch during baking, laying the groundwork for changes that continue during storage.

Those changes affect texture as well as moisture. The crust also matters: bread stored with its crust can lose moisture from the crumb differently from bread stored without it.

What Changes in Bread During Baking?

Baking changes wheat-bread starch by making its granules swell and gelatinise. Gelatinisation is the change that happens when starch granules absorb water and heat.

As the granules swell, some amylose—a type of starch molecule—leaches out and forms a gel around the remains of the granules.

The change is not necessarily uniform throughout the loaf: gelatinisation can differ between the top, centre and bottom of the same slice’s crumb. That means the crumb is not one identical structure from edge to edge.

Why Does Bread’s Crumb Get Firmer?

Bread’s crumb firms during storage. This process, called retrogradation, forms a more ordered, partly crystalline structure.

Staling involves more than one mechanism, but amylopectin retrogradation—a rearrangement of another type of starch molecule—is a plausible major contributor. Water enters the newly ordered structures, shifting its distribution between starch and gluten and changing the gluten network.

As bread crumb firms, amylopectin retrogradation can increase while the amount of water able to freeze decreases. These changes help explain why stale bread can feel firmer even when drying alone does not account for the texture.

Is Stale Bread Just Dried-Out Bread?

Moisture loss matters, but it does not explain every change in bread’s texture. A storage test kept white bread with or without its crust in sealed pouches at 25°C for two weeks.

In the bread stored with its crust, crumb moisture and water activity—the availability of water in the crumb—fell significantly. Both stayed relatively unchanged in bread stored without its crust.

After more than seven days, the bread stored with its crust was firmer and had more amylopectin recrystallisation than the bread stored without it. The causes of the initial firming during the first seven days were not conclusive, so the early texture change cannot be attributed to one clear cause.

Why Can the Fridge Make Bread Stale Faster?

Bread can stale faster in a refrigerator because starch retrogradation was fastest at 4°C in a comparison with storage at 25°C and −18°C. Bread stored at −18°C maintained almost constant water activity for 23 days.

Heating can soften stale bread, although the effect depends on its storage conditions. In one bread-refreshing experiment, bread was heated at 90°C for 45 minutes; bread that had been stored at 2°C for two days regained its original firmness after heating.

By contrast, bread stored at 30°C recovered only part of its original firmness after the same heating treatment.

Key facts

Fastest retrogradation
In a comparison of 4°C, 25°C and −18°C, starch retrogradation was fastest at 4°C.
Crust and crumb moisture
In bread stored at 25°C for two weeks, crumb moisture and water activity fell significantly when the bread was stored with its crust.
Bread stored frozen
Bread stored at −18°C maintained almost constant water activity for 23 days.
Heating stale bread
After heating at 90°C for 45 minutes, bread stored at 2°C for two days regained its original firmness.

Questions people ask

Does bread go stale because it dries out?

Moisture loss matters, but it is not the whole explanation. Starch retrogradation also changes the crumb’s structure and firmness.

Why does bread get hard when it gets old?

During storage, starch molecules reassociate into more ordered structures. Amylopectin retrogradation is a plausible major contributor to the crumb becoming firmer.

Does bread go stale faster in the fridge?

Starch retrogradation was fastest at 4°C in a comparison with 25°C and −18°C, so refrigeration can speed this part of staling.

Can heating make stale bread soft again?

Heating restored the original firmness of bread stored at 2°C for two days in one experiment, while bread stored at 30°C recovered only partly.

Sources

  1. Impact of Local Hydrothermal Treatment During Bread Baking on Soluble Amylose, Firmness, Amylopectin Retrogradation and Water Mobility During Bread Staling — Journal of Food Science and Technology · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  2. Bread Staling: Molecular Basis and Control — Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety · ift.onlinelibrary.wiley.com
  3. Moisture Redistribution and Phase Transitions During Bread Staling — Cereal Chemistry · onlinelibrary.wiley.com
  4. Effect of Storage Temperature on Starch Retrogradation of Bread Staling — Starch - Stärke · onlinelibrary.wiley.com
  5. Bread Staling Studies. II. The Role of Refreshening — Cereal Chemistry · cerealsgrains.org

More in Food

All 22 articles

The Science of Coffee: How Caffeine Affects Your Brain

Discover the fascinating science behind coffee and caffeine as we explore how they affect the brain. Learn about the stimulating effects, neurotransmitter modulation, tolerance, and health considerations for enjoying coffee in moderation.