The only eyewitness account of the 1621 harvest feast at Plymouth, Massachusetts, never mentions turkey. Edward Winslow, who was there, wrote that four men went "fowling" and that the Wampanoag guests brought five deer. Turkey became the star of Thanksgiving mostly in the 1800s, helped along by one determined writer and magazine editor, Sarah Josepha Hale.
Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26, in 2026. Here is what the records say was on the table in 1621, and how one bird took over the holiday.
The Claim: Did the Pilgrims Eat Turkey at the First Thanksgiving?
Many Americans learn that the English settlers of Plymouth and their Wampanoag guests shared a roast turkey in 1621, and that this meal started the holiday. The claim, in short: turkey was the centerpiece of the 1621 feast, and that meal is the reason we eat it today.
The gathering is remembered as the "First Thanksgiving," but that name was given to it later. Two writings from the time survive, and they are the starting point for everything below.
What the Evidence Shows About the 1621 Feast
Only two sources from the time mention the 1621 harvest celebration, and Winslow's letter is the only one that describes it. Winslow wrote it on December 11, 1621, and it was printed in London in 1622 in a book known as Mourt's Relation.
In the original spelling, Winslow says "our governour sent foure men on fowling, that so we might after a speciall manner rejoyce together." Fowling means hunting wild birds, and he does not name the birds. He adds that the Wampanoag leader Massasoit (also written Ousamequin) came "with some ninetie men, whom for three dayes we entertained and feasted." The Wampanoag men "went out and killed five Deere, which they brought to the Plantation."
Turkey appears in the other source, William Bradford's history Of Plymouth Plantation, but in a passage about the autumn in general: "besids water foule ther was great store of wild Turkies, of which they tooke many, besids venison." Pilgrim Hall Museum notes that this describes the abundance that fall, not the feast itself.
Historians at Plimoth Patuxet Museums say turkey was probably among the birds eaten, because wild turkeys were plentiful, but they call it probable, not certain. Historian Ashley Rose Young of the Smithsonian's National Museum of American History has said historians do not believe turkey was eaten at the 1621 meal and that the likely meats were venison, geese and duck.
What was most likely on the table
- Venison: the five deer brought by the Wampanoag guests.
- Wildfowl: ducks and geese are likely, and quail and passenger pigeon are possible.
- Seafood: cod, sea bass, mussels, lobster and eel were part of the local diet. Bradford wrote that the settlers took "good store" of cod and bass.
- Corn: flint corn, eaten as porridge, puddings and flatbread. The Wampanoag made nasaump (corn porridge) and sobaheg (stew).
- Vegetables and fruit: beans, squash, pumpkin, onions and other garden crops, plus wild cranberries, grapes and nuts.
What was almost certainly not there
- Potatoes: not yet adopted in England or North America.
- Pumpkin pie: pumpkin was probably served, but early pumpkin recipes came later and were not pies. Plymouth lacked the butter and wheat flour for crusts.
- Apple pie: no apples grew in Plymouth yet.
- Cranberry sauce: not recorded in print until about 50 years later.
- Forks: diners used knives, spoons and their hands.
Who was at the table
About 50 English settlers had survived the winter of 1620, and Massasoit arrived with about 90 men, so well over 100 people shared the food. The English were the hosts, and the Wampanoag contributed the deer. Plimoth Patuxet says the four surviving adult English women, with help from teenagers, children and servants, were the likely cooks, and that the number of Wampanoag women present is unknown.
Historians describe the occasion as partly diplomatic. The English wanted to keep the alliance made with Massasoit in April 1621, and the Wampanoag, weakened by the epidemic known as the Great Dying of about 1616 to 1619, had reasons to seek good relations too. Many details of the three days are not recorded.
The Wampanoag view
For many Native people, the story told about 1621 leaves out what followed. Since 1970, Native Americans and others have gathered each Thanksgiving on Cole's Hill in Plymouth for the National Day of Mourning. It began with Frank James (Wamsutta) of the Aquinnah Wampanoag, who had been invited to speak at an anniversary event but was told his remarks were too inflammatory, so he spoke on Cole's Hill instead. The Smithsonian's National Museum of American History notes that the "First Thanksgiving" story left out the Wampanoag perspective and the devastating events after 1621.
The Verdict
Verdict: Myth, as the story is usually told. Turkey was not the centerpiece of the 1621 feast in any record, and no document says it was served. It may have been among the "fowl," since wild turkeys were abundant, but that is an inference. What the records do name is wildfowl and five deer.
Why Turkey Became the Centerpiece
Turkey became the Thanksgiving bird through a novel, a campaign and a presidential proclamation, not through the 1621 meal. The first big push came in 1827, when Sarah Josepha Hale published the novel Northwood, with a detailed description of a New England Thanksgiving dinner. In it, "The roasted turkey took precedence on this occasion, being placed at the head of the table."
Hale later became an editor at the magazine Godey's Lady's Book, one of the most widely read American magazines of its day, and used it to campaign for a single national Thanksgiving day on the last Thursday of November. Her editorials ran for decades. On September 28, 1863, she wrote to President Abraham Lincoln asking him to proclaim the holiday.
Lincoln issued the proclamation on October 3, 1863, during the Civil War, after the Battle of Gettysburg. It asked citizens to "set apart and observe the last Thursday of November next." Secretary of State William Seward wrote it. After President Franklin Roosevelt moved the holiday a week earlier in 1939 to lengthen the shopping season, Congress fixed it by law in 1941 as the fourth Thursday of November, and Roosevelt signed the bill.
Practical reasons kept turkey on the table. Young says turkey was native to North America and already lived on people's properties, and that a 15 to 20 pound turkey can feed many people, unlike a chicken. Troy Bickham, a Texas A&M historian, calls it an "ideal celebration bird" that feeds a crowd and makes a centerpiece. Young also says turkey spread as a national dish as New England harvest foods traveled west with migrating Americans.
Turkey on the Table Today
Turkey is still the main dish for most American Thanksgiving tables. The National Turkey Federation's 2025 survey of 1,000 adults, run by 210 Analytics, found that 94% planned to celebrate Thanksgiving. Of those, 87% said turkey is part of their meal most years and 74% planned to serve a whole bird. The federation estimated that nearly 30 million turkeys would be eaten at Thanksgiving 2025.
The USDA's National Agricultural Statistics Service counted 193.5 million turkeys raised in the United States in 2025. Its September 25, 2026 report forecasts 199 million for 2026, up 3 percent.





